We Are Solving the Wrong Problem About Period Poverty
Each year, we post photos of girls smiling with sanitary pads on our social media. The associated messages say “empowering girls,” “ending period poverty,” or “helping girls stay in school,” among many others. The images are heart-warming. The intentions are honorable. However, what if I tell you that a girl can have sanitary pads and still suffer period poverty? That sounds like a paradox. After all, period poverty means that a person has no access to or can’t afford sanitary pads. By that logic, providing sanitary pads should resolve period poverty, right?
Well, for the millions of women and girls, the answer is a very definite “no.”
Right now in Nigeria, a girl has a sanitary pad in her school bag but no private school toilet. One has school sanitary pads but is too embarrassed to talk about bad menstrual pain because she was told it isn’t something decent girls talk about. One of the girls goes to a school where boys laugh at girls who have stained their uniforms. One girl has stuffed her sanitary pad deep in her clothes to hide the evidence.
If the problem of period poverty were just about supply, these girls would not have to face these challenges. However, period poverty is not just about the supply of pads. This is why we have unsuccessfully tried to treat the disease by only addressing the symptoms.
Over time, supply-based solutions for menstrual health have dominated the discourse. Governments, development partners, non-governmental organizations, and community-based organizations have all put time and resources into supplying sanitary pads for girls.
These initiatives have certainly helped the countless women who would otherwise have had to manage their menstrual problems on their own. On the other hand, the general fixation on menstrual products has created the misconception that period poverty can be fixed with just products. Wrong!
Products such as pads may address the physical side of menstruation, but they leave the underlying issues untouched. Pads can help manage menstrual blood, but they cannot wipe away shame. Stigma and silence surrounding menstruation are two other problems that many menstrual health programs often miss.
The truth I’m referring to here can be found in the girls’ lives. During outreach programs for menstrual health, I have met girls who knew how to use a sanitary pad but could not explain why they menstruate. I have met girls who were afraid of their first period because no one had ever explained it to them. Their challenge was not simply a lack of products; it was a lack of information, support, and safe spaces to learn.
From these experiences, I’ve come to the conclusion that there is no point in supplying menstrual products without also providing adequate information about menstruation. A girl may know how to manage her period physically while still carrying fear, confusion, and shame about a natural biological process.
In many homes and communities, menstruation is still a secret matter not meant for open discussion. In many homes and communities, girls don’t really get to talk about menstruation until they have their first period. Even then, the conversation is often limited to avoiding pregnancy and preventing stains.
Some girls have never heard anyone speak about menstruation positively, and that is why the first spotting of menstrual blood shocks them, and they become extremely fearful. Instead of feeling proud or confident, they become scared and confused, even keeping silent.
When menstruation becomes a taboo topic, girls internalize that shame, and it becomes a part of their identity. They learn how to whisper about their periods, hide their sanitary supplies, and avoid menstrual health conversations, even in cases where they are suffering from pain, discomfort, or health concerns that need to be attended to.
The effects of this secrecy go on well into adult life. A woman who grows up believing that menstruation is something to be ashamed of may feel uncomfortable talking openly with a doctor or seeking a second opinion. She may even avoid going for regular reproductive health check-ups.
After a while, silence becomes a barrier not only to her health but also to her confidence and sense of empowerment. This is the reason period poverty cannot be treated independently of education. If we provide girls with products only, without the necessary education about how to use them, it is like giving a person an atlas and letting them navigate their way without instructions on how to read it.
Girls should know and have a healthy understanding of what their body is going through before they see their first period. They deserve to learn about their period without being afraid, without myths or false stories that are going to interfere with gaining true knowledge.
But even if girls have the right information, it won’t be enough if the environment around them doesn’t meet their basic need. Let’s imagine a girl who is going to sit in a classroom for six hours after getting her period and is trying as best as she can to be discreet about it. Now picture that her school is not connected to running water, the toilet is broken, and there is neither a disposal system nor a privacy box available where she could secretly change her sanitary product.
We would wonder if the availability of a single pad solves all her problems. Menstrual health management is also a public health and facility management matter.
Without clean water and sanitation facilities, it won’t be possible for a girl to manage her menstrual needs with the dignity she deserves.
The same goes for when she has to attend classes; it becomes impossible for her to ease her concerns about staining, pain, or humiliation, so her ability to learn diminishes. She is not going to concentrate in class when her essential needs are completely disregarded.
We praise the provision of pads, but at the same time, we disregard the situation that leads girls to menstrual distress in the first place. If a girl is absent from classes because she is menstruating, learning is going to drop. If a girl is not a part of school activities because of fear or shame, her ability to interact with peers will drop.
When a girl feels lost and devalued in a society where menstruation is treated as something that should not be talked about, it can affect other girls too. Gradually, small disadvantages add up and transform into major inequalities.
Menstruation is an example of a health, education, gender equality, and human rights topic at once.
On one hand, we cannot claim to support the girl child’s education without actively addressing the barriers that make it difficult for her to learn comfortably. We can hardly call that gender equality when we still treat a natural and healthy process like menstruation as something to be embarrassed about.
And, if our ultimate aim is the development and empowerment of girls, then we need to create an environment where they can grow, learn, and feel respected. I guess people don’t really grasp that the key point of period poverty is respect.
When we advocate for girls’ education, we simply cannot ignore or remain indifferent to the fact that there are barriers that affect their ability to go to school. When our cultural beliefs make girls feel ashamed of a natural biological process, we cannot truly claim to be committed to gender equality.
By simply speaking about girls’ empowerment without actually creating an environment that values their dignity, we are not actually helping girls. It is probably the least discussed but the most profound issue related to the lack of sanitary facilities and menstrual hygiene: the human right and personal worth of individuals to be free from shame and indignity.
The human dignity factor cannot be quantified by the number of sanitary towels given out. Nor will it feature in a report of a new initiative or in the statistics of an awareness campaign. Still, it is a major reason why one girl may simply endure her period while another can go through it with ease and confidence.
Dignity is coming to school without being worried about stigma, getting the necessary knowledge without facing prejudice, being able to consult a doctor without feeling humiliated, and living in a society that is not only familiar with but also respectful of the subject of menstruation.
Ultimately, the idea of dignity is to acknowledge that a woman’s cycle should never be something that prevents her from getting involved, going to school, getting an opportunity, or pursuing any form of employment.
If we genuinely want to solve period poverty, we must move beyond charity-based solutions that focus on products alone. Although giving out free menstrual products offers short-term relief, it does not solve the problem because period poverty has deeper roots in societal structures and inequalities.
Change can only come when we decide to stop quantifying sanitary pads and begin getting rid of the obstacles that hinder girls from education, development, and learning.
Ultimately, the problem is not getting more menstrual supplies but changing our perception of success. Every time we praise a menstrual health action, there is another question we need to ask ourselves: Did we simply hand out stuff, or did we also help build a person’s worth?
Having a sanitary pad does not mean a girl has escaped period poverty. Without information, privacy, support, and a voice, she can still struggle with her period.
Until we understand that having a sanitary pad alone does not solve period poverty, we will keep counting the number of pads we give out while overlooking the opportunities these girls continue to lose.
Perhaps this is what happens when we tackle the wrong problem: we solve one issue while overlooking the challenges that continue to hold girls back.